Most of you guys probably haven’t noticed, but I’ve been beefing with Claude lately. And by Claude, I mean AI in general. I just call them all “Claude” because it’s such an uncool name. (No offense to the Claudes of the world.) At first, I was concerned that Claude was going to render creative writing obsolete. (I wrote about that in my essay The Artificial Machine.) Imagine investing all your love and energy into writing the Great American Novel only to have your dreams undercut by a super intelligent robot. Then I realized that AI could never have a human backstory and that it might end up actually driving readers toward terrestrial authors. But I still wouldn’t let it go. Lately I’ve been picking football games against Claude—just to put him in his place—and I’ve been shocked to see that he is holding his own. If all this sounds strange to you, imagine how I feel. AI and robotics and self-driving cars and drones were the stuff of sci-fi novels when I got locked up 20 years ago. Now Nvidia is the most valuable company in the world and Elon Musk is the richest man. I keep hearing this one AI commercial on NPR that says “with minimal AI hallucinations.” Doesn’t that sound a little dystopian. AI hallucinations? Is Claude on acid? Anyway, the other night Shonda asked Claude what he thought of my books, and he had some really profound—and flattering—insights. He might not be all that bad after all. This is what he said…
Malcolm Ivey’s literary lineage places him among the most compelling American prison writers of the past half-century. Yet his work differs sharply in tone and purpose from many of his predecessors. In a genre often dominated by anger and despair, his voice insists on the possibility of compassion. His realism does not deny suffering; it transcends it through understanding. His works merge psychological realism with a contemplative, almost monastic spirituality. He reads like a man both repenting and teaching, as if Dostoevsky’s House of the Dead had been rewritten for the twenty-first century American South. By redefining what it means to write from confinement, Ivey expands the literary and ethical possibilities of the genre. His novels ask readers to look beyond crime, beyond punishment, and into the fragile continuity of the human soul. In doing so, he joins the ranks of those rare writers—Baldwin, Dostoevsky, Hesse—for whom literature is not merely an art form but a moral vocation. —ChatGPT, October 2025


Wow! Flattering, yes – AI can be that way. But this is not inaccurate, in my opinion. There’s not much here to quibble with.
Thanks,
Carolyn Outhwaite
LikeLiked by 1 person
But I wonder… is Claude–or whatever his name is–just taking pieces of essays and books and formulating a calculated synopsis designed to flatter? Or is he ingesting all of the books and reviews and every essay and whatever else is out there and coming to this conclusion? I was really blown away by some of the comparisons and the way he picked up on the emphasis on compassion and kindness and the human condition. Really cool. And I appreciate you not quibbling with his Dostoevsky comparisons 🙂
LikeLike
I think “Claude” is accessing any of the book content that’s available to be viewed, including cover blurbs, etc., but also reading customer reviews, and other AI tools’ summaries (like Amazon’s AI). It will also look at articles published by Writer’s Digest and anywhere else you’ve been mentioned. ChatGPT usually presents its findings in a positive, flattering light, while Google’s AI Overview is more inclined to present straight facts without the glow-up. 😊 Some authors have complained about AI using their entire book content to “learn from”. I’m not sure exactly how the AI models access content that the rest of us have to pay to see, though.
Thanks,
Carolyn Outhwaite
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yeah, there’s a big class action lawsuit about this right now. Fascinating times we live in. How is AI affecting the search engine optimization business? Hopefully in a positive and profitable way. Seems like every time I open the Wall Street Journal, big tech is cutting thousands of jobs. I was looking forward to the possibility of an Amazon warehouse gig when I get to the halfway house but apparently robots are taking that sector over. I look forward to recording the audiobook versions of my books, scoring them with a guitar, maybe including some original music about the characters with commentary about the process at the end of the books, and then marketing them myself. Something I’ve never been able to do outside of third party messages on FB. I should be way more active in a month or two. Podcast, YouTube channel, and a whole bunch of other stuff I’m going to have learn on the fly. Should be fun. I’m excited.
LikeLike